As you could tell from my review, last year, I fell in love with the first season of Only Murders in the Building. The set-up, the characters and especially the writing were near perfection to me, so I was very excited to come back to this show. However, there is always the worry that they won’t capture that lightening the second time around. So how did all these elements stack up this time?
The story
This season follows directly on from the cliff-hanger of the last, with the murder of the buildings board president Bunny. But, since she was found with Mabel, in her apartment, she and the group are prime suspects in the murder investigation this time around. So, as well as investigating the murder for their podcast, the trio now have the added task of clearing their names of suspicion.
This extra layer is a great way of upping the anti for the second season, making it different enough but not changing the premise too much. It did make the story a little more complicated this time, which isn’t necessarily a bad thing. The drawback for me was that it did mean there was less time focussed on the podcasting, which was the main framing device of the first season, and I did miss it a bit. Overall though still a compelling story with plenty of twists and turns to keep you guessing.
The characters
The main trio of characters is just entertaining and engaging as the last time, but importantly, they did manage to still reveal things about the characters we didn’t know before. This was in the form of things from their past as well as how they handle things into the present, leading to their journeys through this series. By the end of the season, each of them feels like they’re in a different place than they were at the end of the last one, which is really exciting for moving the show forward.
In terms of new characters, we have Cara Delevigne as Mabel’s new love interest, and art gallery owner Alice. To be honest I’m not a big Cara Delevigne fan so I wasn’t super jazzed about seeing her here. Alice as a character was fine, she was just there. I don’t think she really added much to the story and I wouldn’t be bothered about having her come back next season. However, I do appreciate them adding more people in Mabel’s age range to interact with the group, to make her feel a little less out of place.
But the new character I enjoyed the most was Zoe Colletti as Charles’ teenage ex-stepdaughter(ish) Lucy, who re-enters his life after falling out with her mother. Adding kids into things can be a risk as they sometimes end up being annoying, but I think Lucy was old enough to not be too needy and Collette has enough experience to play the role well. I really loved Lucy’s dynamic with the rest of the group, as the three different generations now clash but also find that common ground like the older guys did with Mabel previously. And what’s key to Lucy is that she actually helps with the case, meaning she serves a purpose in the main storyline as well as with Charles’ sub plot.
Finally, I have to give a mention to the legend that is Shirley MacLaine who appears in two episodes this season. She’s not onscreen for long, but she’s of course completely captivating when she is.
The writing
Like last time, most of the comedy comes from the meta jokes on murder mystery shows, using the titular podcast as a way to do that. Of course, there are plenty of jokes about the nature of a second season, with characters talking about the expectations being higher or complaining that the second season wasn’t as good. The way the writers impeccably worked these in so naturally to the dialogue is just chefs kiss to me, and it always makes me laugh.
I do have to agree with some of the character’s complaints though, as I did feel the mystery wasn’t as tight as the last one. Some things tended to just with not much explanation, and especially some things that I find weird that they come up last time around. For example, Mabel has a few blackouts where she can’t remember what’s happened to her, which is supposedly something she’s always done. But I don’t remember that ever happening last time when it easily could have. The mystery overall wasn’t as compelling for me, until I reached the final few episodes, and I found myself often more interested in the side stories going on.
However, the set up for the next murder mystery in the already greenlit season 3 was very fun and I can’t wait to see where it goes.
If you haven’t watched this show already, or you haven’t caught up on the second season, I will continue to recommend. It’s such an entertaining show, and it’s so charming that it becomes really comforting.
I don’t know how many more seasons the premise can handle so I have a feeling the next season will be it’s last. It say watch it now while it’s at its peak and get hyped for the next season to drop in 2023.